(11-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Loverboy Wrote: [ -> ]What is the psychology of why athlete fans are so desperate to believe that their heroes are natural? I see 30+ year old grown men say for example Evander Holyfield was on steroids but their own favorite, Mike Tyson, wasnt and was a "genetic freak". Why are people so eager to believe?
Firstly, I’m not a boxing expert, so apologies for everyone in advance. I think that in this case the saying “false evidence appearing real” is at least one of the reasons why people want to believe. Mike is and was the wet dream of every casual boxing fan. Back at the day, he was one of the big superstars in the world, and rightly so. He became the youngest heavyweight champion of the world, and to my knowledge, he still is. It’s like the late great hall of fame boxing trainer Manny Steward said, Mike did more to boxing, especially to heavyweight boxing than any other boxer after Ali. Steward also recalled how during Tyson’s prime in the 80’s, people would leave from the clubs etc. at night just to see Mike fight and destroy his opponent. Brutal KOs with heads snapping back and all that. Even though most of Mike’s fights took only a round or two, everybody wanted to se him fight.
Mike also had a compelling story. Coming from rags to riches and getting under the tutelage of Cus D’Amato who mold him into a fighting machine. The fascinating peek-a-boo style and all the real fear that Mike instilled in his opponents. And the fake stories of Mike being being a nephew of Sonny Liston. How he avenged Ali’s loss to Holmes. All these things grew his legendary story. People really were into him, the Kid Dynamite. He even got his own Nintendo game.
I think Evander wasn’t ever really loved that much by the general public. Although as a fighter he was much more than Mike. He came to heavyweight from the lower weight class. Probably did it better than anyone has ever done, to this day. He fought all the best fighters, many of them multiple times. Technical boxer, great ring IQ, he had everything. And many think that contrary to Mike, Evander also had that iron will that Mike seemed to lack when things actually got tough.
To me, many seem to remember the controversies over Evander. It’s said that Mike was really BIG from a very young age, even though short, he was heavy and without fat. It’s also said that he was beating up grown up men who actually knew how to box at a time when young Mike didn’t really know how to box himself. Judging from the stories, people may believe he just was a big guy from the beginning. When Evander jumped from cruiserweight to heavyweight. he did seem to grow a lot. He also ended up with all the classic symptoms of PED-usage. Hair loss, 3D-shoulders, enormous traps and gynecomastia. His face seemed suddenly very old too. Then he had the notorious “Evan Fields” incident, where he had ordered testosterone and growth hormone and whatnot using the afore mentioned name, Evan Fields. I don’t remember all about the incident and I’m too lazy to check the facts but the stories can be easily found in the web. Holyfield also did have some heart problems during his career if I remember correctly.
In the end, I think Holyfield’s usage was just too evident and transparent for people. He also had a lot of bad luck and bad media tension. And it looks like he really had a great response to all those drugs in bodybuilding sense which of course made it worse. Mike’s aura seemed to protect his reputation better when it comes to PEDs. At least in eyes of a regular sports fan. Of course the truth is a bit different, TS has actually gone through with this long time ago in the article
https://nattyornot.com/mike-tyson/.
I really think that Evander just had bad luck, similarly to how Larry Holmes who never seems to get enough praise of his career because of the way he won Ali. To me they were all drugged in the 80’s. At least the heavyweights, for example Frank Bruno. Google the name and you’ll see. People have just always fell in love with Mike and his story. And it’s the same with any sport, or with movie stars. People just love them, and they don’t want to believe.